The rhetoric and visuals from the Russian leader Vladimir Putin's recent official trip to India spoke of a enduring bilateral relationship. Indian PM Narendra Modi welcomed Putin at the airport with a hug, and the leaders took a ride together, echoing a familiar political style. In his comments, Modi called Putin as "a dear friend" and described the India-Russia connection as a "guiding star", built on "shared respect and deep trust" that had "weathered the test of time". This was Putin's tenth visit to India over his 25-year tenure and his twentieth meeting with Modi since the latter took office in 2014.
A Chasm Separating Symbolism and Substance
Yet, a noticeable gap exists between the ceremony and the actual content of this relationship. Although Putin pledged "continuous fuel supplies" to India, the country's companies are actually buying less Russian oil because of international pressure. The two countries concluded a series of memorandums of understanding covering mobility, health, agriculture, naval cooperation, and academic exchanges. However, anticipated announcements on major military contracts did not materialize. India has not concluded any major defence agreements with Russia following the 2022's invasion of Ukraine, a trend fueled by holdups in deliveries of platforms and spare parts as Moscow focuses on its own wartime requirements.
A Relationship Losing Strategic Heft
These developments suggests that the Indo-Russian relationship no longer carries the same geopolitical weight it previously did. In the era of superpower rivalry, India enjoyed special barter arrangements and economic entry to the USSR and its allies. This unique alliance reached its pinnacle in 1971 with a Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Cooperation, signed ahead of a conflict with Pakistan where Islamabad was backed by the US and China. Although both countries have sought to maintain a semblance of this close bond through a "unique and elevated" strategic partnership declared in 2010, the reality is that their interaction does not have the former importance as New Delhi has substantially deepened ties with the Western world.
Broadening and Underlying Contradictions
New Delhi is not expected to sever its crucial links with Moscow. Yet, as external coercion mounts on India to curtail its purchases of Russian oil, both nations are seeking to diversify the partnership into new sectors. On Putin's visit, they announced an joint economic programme extending until 2030, designed to make their relations "more diversified, balanced and long-lasting". This includes enhancing entry for Indian products to rectify a trade deficit strongly tilted in Russia's favour. Collaboration between the two covers several key strategic fields – from aerospace and atomic energy to defence and food security.
Ideological Affinity and Seen Reliability
At an sentimental plane, a high degree of affinity with Russia remains, particularly among senior generations of officials in New Delhi who recall Moscow's crucial support during the Cold War. This has resulted in a certain level of sympathy for the Russian narrative on the Ukraine war. Amid ongoing tensions between India and the US, where American officials have issued critical remarks about the Indian economy, many in India see Russia as a more reliable ally.
This key difficulty, of course, is the ongoing war in Ukraine.
The comprehensive joint statement issued during Putin's India trip made no mention to Ukraine, even though it ironically referred to the relationship as an "pillar of global peace and stability". Despite Modi's often-repeated statement that "now is not the era of war", New Delhi's public steps regarding the war have been minimal.
Squaring the Dilemma: India's Global Balancing Act
This situation does not belie the inherent contradictions in India's foreign policy. The country is poised to conclude a trade deal with the European Union, after a comparable agreement with the UK this year. On the sidelines, India, Australia, and Canada declared a three-way technology initiative. There are ten times more Indian students in the US than in Russia, although moves are being made to boost cultural contacts between India and Russia.
How can India square this complex equation? New Delhi will be hoping that ongoing talks will succeed, leading to a cessation of hostilities and the elimination of a key thorn in its relations with the Western bloc. But, should a peace deal is reached, if it fails of a "just peace" that upholds Ukraine's independence and borders, critical examination of the India-Russia alliance will undoubtedly continue in Western governments.